Back to the Atlas

Scene · Year one

The potions riddle

A test of logic, not a flick of the wand.

Appearances: Philosopher’s Stone (1997 / 2001)

The book

Source-verified

Hermione uses logic to identify the bottles that allow passage through fire.

The film

Source-verified

This protection of the Stone is omitted.

The HBO series

Awaiting evidence

No portrayal or scene evidence has been verified for this entry. Comparisons will be added after source review.

Source notes

J. K. Rowling, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (1997), chapter 16.

Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, dir. Chris Columbus (2001), theatrical release.

Chapter 16; film trapdoor sequence.

Test your first-year knowledge